Texas Court of Appeals, 1st District (Houston) September 30, 2010, 01-10-00167-CV (Mettauer v. Noble)
Also known as
United States · · · 30-09-2010
OPINION
TERRY JENNINGS, Justice.
In this interlocutory appeal,
1
appellant, Mark M. Mettauer, M.D., challenges the trial court’s order denying his motion to dismiss the health care liability claim
2
of appellees, Helen Noble, individually and as independent executrix of the estate of Anthony M. Noble, deceased, Alexandria Noble Barcak, Sasha Noble, Danielle Heller, and Vanessa Noble (collectively, the “Nobles”). In two issues, Dr. Mettauer contends that the trial court erred in finding that the Nobles’ expert report, written by Dr. Joseph Carey, is sufficient, determining that Dr. Carey is a qualified expert,
3
and not dismissing the claim. The Nobles contend that Dr. Mettauer has brought this appeal “only to delay the trial and increase the cost” of the case, and they seek sanctions for his bringing of a frivolous appeal.
4
We affirm.
Background
In their original petition, the Nobles, asserting a health care liability claim against Dr. Mettauer, allege that he, while conducting a thoracoscopic atrial ablation on the decedent, and unable to visualize a catheter, negligently continued with the procedure and “tore a hole in the right atrial-inferior vena-cava junction of the [decedent’s] heart.” Dr. Mettauer then, instead of a “medial sternotomy incision,” performed a “right posterolateral thoraco-tomy to open the [decedent’s] chest and repair the injury,” causing an “extensive period of time before blood flow could be reestablished to [the decedent’s] body and organs.” The lack of blood flow caused “catastrophic multiple organ failure,” which resulted in death.
The Nobles timely served Dr. Mettauer with the expert report of Dr. Joseph S. Carey, who opined that the standard of care for thoracoscopic surgery generally requires a surgeon to “visualize through the camera the catheter used during the procedure” and Dr. Mettauer deviated from the standard of care by continuing “with the thoracoscopic ablation procedure when he could not visualize the blue catheter.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit