District Court, D. Maine March 23, 2010, Criminal 09-200-P-H-02 (United States v. Osman)
Also known as
United States · · · 23-03-2010
ORDER ON DEFENDANT’S MOTION FOR RELIEF FROM PREJUDICIAL JOINDER OF COUNTS AND DEFENDANTS
D. BROCK HORNBY, District Judge.
The defendant Dahabo Osman is charged with co-defendant Ahmed Guled in a twenty-three count Indictment. Indictment (Docket Item 3). She moves to sever counts and defendants for improper joinder under Rule 8 and to obtain relief from prejudicial joinder under Rule 14. She wants me to divide the Indictment into three “sets” of counts for trial: (1) Counts 1-6 involving both defendants (she characterizes it as fraud involving health care benefits from MaineCare
1
); (2) Counts 9-11, 16-17, and 22-23, involving her alone (she says failing to disclose income in order to qualify for government benefits); and (3) Counts 7-8, 12-15, and 18-21, involving Guled alone (she says failing to disclose income and assets in order to qualify for government benefits). The time period covered by the criminal charges in the Indictment is 2006 to 2009. The motion is Denied.
Improper Joinder
Osman’s argument is that Rule 8(b) “does not allow for the joinder of defendants when the counts respective to each defendant are unrelated.” Defendant’s Motion for Relief from Prejudicial Joinder
*163
of Counts and Defendants at 8 (Docket Item 23). But the Indictment charges Osman and Guled jointly with both health care fraud (Count 2) and conspiracy to commit health care fraud (Count 1). Rule 8(b) explicitly allows joinder of two or more defendants “if they are alleged to have participated in the same act or transaction ... constituting an offense or offenses.” Fed.R.Crim.P. 8(b). Clearly, then, joinder is proper on Counts 1 and 2, and Osman concedes that joinder is also proper as to Counts 3-6 which, she says, “concern conduct related in substance and form to the allegations contained in Counts 1 and 2.” Defendant’s Motion for Relief from Prejudicial Joinder of Counts and Defendants at 2.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit