Court of Appeals of Oregon October 27, 2010, 06C19006; A138878 (Crismon v. Parks)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-10-2010

*314

SERCOMBE, J.

In this personal injury action, plaintiff appeals a jury verdict awarding her damages for injuries that she sustained in an automobile accident with defendant, contending that the trial court erred in declining to give her requested uniform jury instruction and that the failure to give the requested instruction resulted in a verdict that did not fully compensate plaintiff for her injuries. We conclude that the trial court erred in failing to give the instruction and reverse.

A party is entitled to jury instructions consistent with her theory of the case, provided that the instructions (1) correctly state the law; (2) are based on the current pleadings; and (3) are supported by evidence.

Hernandez v. Barbo Machinery Co.,

327 Or 99, 101 n 1, 106, 957 P2d 147 (1998);

Fuller v. Merten,

173 Or App 592, 596-97, 22 P3d 1221 (2001). A jury instruction is supported by the evidence “if there was any competent evidence to support it.”

Carter v. Mote,

285 Or 275, 279, 590 P2d 1214 (1979) (quoting

Manning v. Helbock et al.,

135 Or 262, 266, 295 P 207 (1931)). In reviewing the trial court’s ruling rejecting the requested instruction, we view the evidence in the light “most favorable to the establishment of facts necessary to require giving the instruction.”

Hernandez,

327 Or at 101 n 1.

Plaintiff was injured when her vehicle was struck from behind by defendant’s vehicle. After the accident, plaintiff began experiencing pain in her low back. Both plaintiffs doctor and defendant’s expert opined that plaintiff had experienced a muscle strain. The medical evidence at trial also established that plaintiff has a genetic condition known as a pars defect, which is a gap in the bony ring behind a vertebra. When a person has a pars defect, the vertebrae are more susceptible to shifting, causing a condition known as spondylol-isthesis. Diagnostic tests revealed that plaintiff has spondy-lolisthesis at the L5-S1 level of her spine.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.