Court of Appeals of Oregon October 6, 2010, 071153442; A138713 (State v. HREN)
Also known as
United States · · · 06-10-2010
*607
ARMSTRONG, J.
Defendant appeals her conviction for second-degree theft, ORS 164.045. She assigns error to the exclusion of her testimony that she had been told by a Macy’s employee that she could take the item that she was charged with stealing: a bottle of perfume used by customers as a “tester” bottle. The state concedes that the trial court erred in excluding the testimony but argues that the exclusion was harmless because there was little likelihood that the excluded evidence would have affected the jury’s verdict. We disagree with the state’s harmless error argument and, accordingly, reverse and remand.
On this record, the jury could have found the following facts. Defendant removed a tester bottle of perfume from the fragrance counter of a Macy’s department store and concealed the bottle in the sleeve of her long-sleeved shirt. Defendant left the store without paying for the bottle of perfume and was quickly apprehended by two Macy’s loss prevention employees, one of whom had observed defendant’s actions. Defendant attempted to escape the employees. During the ensuing struggle, defendant dropped the tester bottle on the ground and kicked it into the street. The employees gained control over defendant and took her to an office in the store. While there, one of the employees asked defendant why she had taken the bottle, and she answered that she had taken it for her sister. The state charged defendant with second-degree theft.
At trial, defendant sought to testify that a clerk at the store’s fragrance counter had told her that she could take the tester bottle. The trial court excluded the evidence as hearsay. The state concedes that the evidence was not hearsay. We accept the state’s concession as well taken.
Hearsay is an out-of-court statement offered to prove the truth of the matter asserted. OEC 801(3). Statements that are relevant to show their effect on a listener are not hearsay.
See, e.g., State
v.
Thomas,
167 Or App 80, 84, 1 P3d 1058 (2000).
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit