Supreme Court of Georgia July 12, 2010, S10A1107 (City of Hoschton v. Horizon Communities)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-07-2010

Thompson, Justice.

This appeal arises out of a dispute between appellants (City of Hoschton, Georgia, and its mayor, Bill Copenhaver) and appellees (Horizon Communities, LLC, Gary Olsson Properties, LLC, and their principals, Kenneth and Kelley Gary (collectively “Horizon”)). The city appeals from the trial court’s judgment directing the mayor and city to pay Horizon $191,631 for the construction of the Brook Glen pump station (the BGPS), plus costs and attorney fees.

As found by the trial court, in 2004 the city determined certain improvements were necessary for its public sewer system. The city entered into discussions with Horizon, whereby Horizon would construct a new sewer pump station sufficient to serve certain of Horizon’s proposed developments, but which also would be sufficiently large to serve other developments and properties. In return, Horizon would recoup the portion of its investment serving other developments and properties by cost sharing with other developers and receiving payments from the city through future sewer connection and tap fees. Based on these discussions, in 2005 the city attorney drafted and the city council passed an ordinance with regard to Horizon’s proposed Brook Glen subdivision. The ordinance provided, in pertinent part:

Developer shall be responsible and pay for all costs for infrastructure sewer improvements that serve the development. Sewer design shall be approved by the city engineer. Developer shall dedicate the new sewer infrastructure to the city but reserves the right to recoup a portion of the investment from subsequent development on a lot tap basis on or before June 6, 2010.

The city engineer approved Horizon’s design of the BGPS to handle the Brook Glen subdivision plus several other specified development projects, including Creekside Village, and the pump station was constructed according to that plan.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.