District Court, S.D. New York February 22, 2010, 06 Civ. 7601 (DAB) (Kansas v. EMPIRE CITY SUBWAY CO.(LTD.))

Also known as

United States · · · 22-02-2010

MEMORANDUM AND ORDER

DEBORAH A. BATTS, District Judge.

Before the Court are two Motions: (1) Defendant Empire City Subway’s (“Empire”) Motion to Strike Defendant City of New York’s (“NYC”) Answer or Impose Additional Fed.R.Civ.P. 37 Sanctions; and (2) NYC’s Motion for Summary Judgment. For the reasons below. Empire’s Motion to Strike or Impose Additional Rule 37 Sanctions is DENIED and NYC’s Motion for Summary Judgment is GRANTED in its entirety.

I. FACTUAL BACKROUND

Plaintiff James Kansas testified that on May 6, 2006, at approximately 10:30 P.M., he was injured when he fell while walking in the western cross-walk located at 8th Avenue and 42nd Street in New York City. (PI. Dep. pp. 14, 30

&

55.) Plaintiff testified that his toe struck a steel plate that was protruding two inches above the roadway.

(Id.

p. 32.) Plaintiff identified the steel plate that allegedly caused his fall and it bore the initials “ECS.” (PL Dep. pp. 53-54; Soto Dep. p. 11.)

On the date of the accident, Defendant Empire was engaged in an excavation in the vicinity of 8th Avenue and 42nd Street at the request and expense of a private corporation, Verizon, Inc. (Soto Dep. pp. 12, 17

&

21-22.) Empire used metal plates in connection with this project at 8th Avenue and 42nd Street, installing and removing the plates on a daily basis to cover the excavation when Empire was not working at the site.

(Id.

pp. 23 & 66-67.)

Empire’s excavation sites were subject to inspection by an agency of NYC.

1

(Id.

pp. 56-58.) If there is an unsafe condition at a jobsite site, NYC could issue a corrective action notice request, summons and/or notice of violation. (Soto Dep. pp. 56-58.) To date, neither Empire or NYC’s search of their records have found any inspection reports, requests for corrective action, written complaints or notices of violation for the Empire’s jobsite at 8th Avenue and 42nd Street during the relevant time period.

(Id.

pp. 57 & 61; Aff. Nalik Zeigler, dated July 8, 2009 ¶ 4; Aff.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.