District of Columbia Court of Appeals August 19, 2010, 08-CV-808 (AMERICAN BUS ASS'N v. District of Columbia)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-08-2010

THOMPSON, Associate Judge:

This case is a challenge by appellants American Bus Association, Inc., National Tour Association, Inc., and United Motor-coach Association, Inc. (the “Associations”), to the validity of a District of Columbia law that requires any charter bus that enters upon the roadways of this jurisdiction to (1) obtain District of Columbia registration, (2) register on an apportioned basis, reflecting mileage driven in the District of Columbia, or (3) obtain a trip permit, costing $50 and valid for a six-day period. Appellants contend that this scheme discriminates against and unduly burdens interstate commerce and therefore violates the so-called dormant Commerce Clause of the United States Constitution. They also argue that the scheme conflicts with the International Registration Plan (the “IRP”), an interstate compact to which the District of Columbia is a signatory. The Superior Court entered summary judgment in favor of appellee District of Columbia (the “District”). We affirm that ruling, agreeing with the Superior Court that appellants have failed to show either a Commerce Clause or an IRP violation.

I. Background

The IRP is an agreement between the 48 contiguous states, the District of Columbia, and ten Canadian provinces.

1

To encourage “the fullest use of the highway system,” the IRP authorizes apportioned registration of commercial vehicles and requires member jurisdictions to grant vehicle registration reciprocity to any vehicle registered in a vehicle’s home (“base”) ju

*206

risdiction.

2

Apportioned registration allows commercial vehicle operators to pay a registration fee to a base jurisdiction, which then allocates and distributes portions of the fee to other jurisdictions in proportion to the miles driven by the vehicle in each jurisdiction.

3

The IRP describes in detail the registration and apportionment rules to which IRP members have agreed to adhere with respect to trucks and other apportionable vehicles.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.