Court of Special Appeals of Maryland November 1, 2010, 1006, September Term, 2009 (Anselmo v. Mayor City Council of Rockville)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-11-2010

*117

THIEME, J.

Appellants,

1

initiated this action in the Circuit Court for Montgomery County seeking judicial review of an April 29, 2008, decision of the City of Rockville Planning Commission (the “Planning Commission”). That decision granted a use permit to and authorized appellee MHP Town Center, Inc. (“MHP”) to build a 109 unit apartment complex on land located at the intersection of 254 North Washington Street and 13 Beall Avenue in Rockville, Maryland. Following a hearing, the circuit court affirmed the Planning Commission’s decision by order entered on June 5, 2009. Appellants filed a timely appeal, raising two issues, which we quote:

1. Whether the decision of the Commission violates the City’s adopted Adequate Public Facilities Ordinance and Adequate Public Facilities Standards.

2. Whether the decision of the Commission was erroneous as a matter of law because it does not contain the findings required by Sections 25-193(a) and 25-681 of the Rockville City Code.

Re-stated, we are asked in this appeal whether the Planning Commission erred by approving MHP’s use application based on an erroneous construction of § 25-808 and § 25-802 of the City of Rockville’s Adequate Public Facilities Ordinance (“APFO”) and its implementing Adequate Public Facilities Standards (“APFS”), and failed to make the findings required by § 25-193(a) and § 25-861 of the APFO. For the reasons set forth below, our answer to both questions is in the affirmative, and the decision of the Planning Commission must be reversed.

Factual Background and Proceedings Below

The property at issue is approximately 2.54 acres and is within the Town Center planning area of the City of Rockville. The property is owned by MHP, which is a wholly owned

*118

subsidiary of Montgomery Housing Partnership, Inc., a private non-profit organization.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.