District Court, D. Maine September 16, 2010, MDL. No. 1-09-MD-2068 (In Re Light Cigarettes Marketing Sales Practices Litigation)
Also known as
United States · · · 16-09-2010
ORDER ON PHILIP MORRIS USA, INC.’S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON PLAINTIFFS’ CLAIMS FOR LACK OF CAUSATION
JOHN A. WOODCOCK, JR., Chief Judge.
In this multi-district litigation, Philip Morris USA, Inc. (PM) moves for summary judgment against six plaintiffs on the ground that because they continued to purchase light cigarettes after learning the truth about them health risks, as a matter of law, they cannot show that PM’s misrepresentations caused them to buy light cigarettes.
1
The Court concludes that whether these plaintiffs relied on PM’s misrepresentations is a factual question and denies PM’s motion.
I. STATEMENT OF FACTS
The Plaintiffs assert state consumer fraud and unjust enrichment claims, alleg
*198
ing that PM misrepresented to consumers that light cigarettes were less harmful than regular cigarettes.
Second Am. Good, Spellman, & Thibodeau Compl.
¶¶ 1-2 (Docket # 91)
(Good Compl.); Corse Compl.,
09-cv-638, Attach. 2 ¶ 16 (Docket # ¶);
2
Haubrich Compl.,
10-cv-76, Attach. 2 ¶ 3 (Docket # 1);
Second Am. Tyrer Compl.
¶¶ 1-3 (Docket # 132)
(Tyrer Compl.).
3
To support their claims, the Plaintiffs testified that they started smoking light cigarettes in reliance on PM’s alleged misrepresentations.
PM’s Statement of Material Facts
Attach. 1,
Good Dep. Tr.
71:7-15, Attach. 2,
Thibodeau Dep. Tr.
33:7-8, Attach. 3,
Spellman Dep. Tr.
87:14-19, Attach. 4,
Tryer Dep. Tr.
87:17-24, Attach. 5,
Haubrich Dep. Tr.
117:23-118:6, Attach. 6,
Corse Dep. Tr.
24:19-25:2 (Docket # 184).
4
The Plaintiffs also testified that they now know the health risks associated with smoking light cigarettes.
Good Dep. Tr.
96:24-97:2;
Thibodeau Dep. Tr.
14:18-15:1;
Spellman Dep. Tr.
19:11-20:24;
Tyrer Dep. Tr.
52:22-53:9;
Haubrich Dep. Tr.
89:24-90:06;
Corse Dep. Tr.
74:9-11. Despite their actual knowledge of the health risks of light cigarettes, each Plaintiff admitted that he or she continued to smoke light cigarettes up to the date of their depositions.
Good Dep. Tr.
99:4-13;
Spellman Dep.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit