District Court, D. Minnesota September 14, 2010, Civ. 10-1970 (RHK/LIB) (Dyrdal v. Enbridge (U.S.), Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-09-2010

MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER

RICHARD H. KYLE, District Judge.

INTRODUCTION

This action arises out of a $40,000 arbitration award in favor of Petitioners Dono

*928

van and Anna Dyrdal (“the Dyrdals”) and against Respondent Enbridge (U.S.), Inc. (“Enbridge”). The Dyrdals have filed a Petition asjdng the Court to modify the award by (1) adding $8,666 in interest and (2) “correcting” it to clarify that it does not include certain types of damages. They ask the Court to then confirm the so-modified award. Enbridge has responded,

inter alia,

by moving to dismiss for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction. For the reasons that follow, its Motion will be granted.

BACKGROUND

In 2004, the Dyrdals, farmland owners in Pennington County, Minnesota, commenced arbitration proceedings against Enbridge, a petroleum pipeline company, claiming that Enbridge’s pipelines were damaging their crops. The Dyrdals sought arbitration pursuant to a January 17, 1950 agreement between Enbridge’s predecessor and the previous owners of the farmland, which provided that pipelines would be buried such that “they will not interfere with the ordinary cultivation” of the land. (Petition Ex. A.) The pipeline company agreed to pay for “any damage to crops, fences and timber which may arise from laying, maintaining, operating or removing said lines,” and the parties agreed to arbitrate any dispute as to the amount of such damages.

(Id.)

A three-arbitrator panel was selected, and on November 22, 2004, the Dyrdals filed a Statement of Claim with the panel seeking $102,958 in crop damage and

“additional

damage to [their] soil and land,” plus injunctive relief requiring Enbridge to lower one of its pipelines.

(Id.

Ex. G (emphasis added).) The panel subsequently ruled, however, that only damages to “crops, fences and timber” were within the arbitration clause and any other claim for relief was beyond its jurisdiction.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.