New York Court of Appeals June 17, 2010, 107 (Jones v. Town of Carroll)
Also known as
United States · · · 17-06-2010
OPINION OF THE COURT
Graffeo, J.
Applying our decisions in
Matter of Syracuse Aggregate Corp. v Weise
(51 NY2d 278 [1980]),
Buffalo Crushed Stone, Inc. v Town of Cheektowaga
(13 NY3d 88 [2009],
rearg denied
13 NY3d 808 [2009]) and
Glacial Aggregates LLC v Town of Yorkshire
(14 NY3d 127 [2010]), we hold that the zoning ordinance at issue in this case, which restricted the development of landfills, does not apply to plaintiffs because they acquired a vested right to use their 50-acre parcel as a landfill for construction and demolition debris before the enactment of the zoning law.
In 1984, plaintiffs Donald and Carol Jones purchased 50 acres of land in an agricultural/residential zoning district in the Town of Carroll, Chautauqua County. In 1989, the Town granted plaintiffs a special use variance that permitted the operation of a construction and demolition (C & D) landfill on the entire parcel, provided that the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC) regulated the landfill. Consistent with the Town’s requirements, plaintiffs obtained a DEC permit later that year allowing landfill operations to commence
*143
on roughly two acres and the permit was subsequently expanded to cover three acres.
1
The landfill continued as an active business, but in 2005, the Town adopted a new zoning law that prohibited the “expansion of any landfill beyond the area and scope allowed under the operators [sic] permit from the DEC as of the date of this Local Law.” Relying on this new restriction, the Town sought to prevent plaintiffs from using the remaining 47 acres of their property for landfill purposes.
Plaintiffs then commenced this action seeking, among other relief, a declaration that the local law could not be validly applied to their property because the use variance and their activities on the land established a right to operate a landfill on all 50 acres.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit