Court of Appeals of Oregon March 17, 2010, 180807477, 180807478 A138928 (Control), A138929 (Swarringim v. Olson)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-03-2010

*311

LANDAU, P. J.

Respondents appeal stalking protective orders (SPOs) entered against them pursuant to ORS 30.866, prohibiting them from having contact with petitioner or her family. Respondents argue that the evidence is insufficient to warrant the issuance of the orders. On

de novo

review,

Osborne v. Fadden,

225 Or App 431, 433, 201 P3d 278,

rev den,

346 Or 213 (2009);

Hanzo v. deParrie,

152 Or App 525, 536-37, 953 P2d 1130 (1998),

rev den,

328 Or 418 (1999), we agree with respondents and reverse.

To obtain an SPO against a person under ORS 30.866(1), a petitioner must demonstrate by a preponderance of the evidence that

“(a) The person intentionally, knowingly or recklessly engages in repeated and unwanted contact with the other person or a member of that person’s immediate family or household thereby alarming or coercing the other person;

“(b) It is objectively reasonable for a person in the victim’s situation to have been alarmed or coerced by the contact; and

“(c) The repeated and unwanted contact causes the victim reasonable apprehension regarding the personal safety of the victim or a member of the victim’s immediate family or household.”

ORS 30.866(1) has both subjective and objective components. To satisfy the subjective component, the petitioner must show that he or she was alarmed or coerced by the contacts, and that the contacts caused apprehension regarding his or her personal safety or the personal safety of a member of his or her immediate family or household. ORS 30.866(l)(a), (c);

Weatherly v. Wilkie,

169 Or App 257, 259, 8 P3d 251 (2000). To satisfy the objective component, “the contacted person’s alarm or coercion must be objectively reasonable” and that person’s apprehension for his or her personal safety must also be objectively reasonable. ORS 30.866(l)(b);

Pinkham v. Brubaker,

178 Or App 360, 372, 37 P3d 186 (2001);

Weatherly,

169 Or App at 259.

ORS 30.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.