District Court of Appeal of Florida September 22, 2010, 4D08-2505 (Hicks v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-09-2010

POLEN, J.

Appellant, Jarvis Hicks, appeals his conviction for attempted first degree murder with a firearm. He argues that the trial court failed to conduct a Richardson

1

hearing upon learning that the State had failed to provide appellant written notice of the substance of his statement to Detective Foster, and failed to identify Foster as a witness to this statement, until the day of trial. We find that the State did not commit a discovery violation by failing to provide appellant with written notice of the substance of his statement. However, we agree with appellant that the State’s failure to identify Detective Foster as a “rebuttal to alibi witness” until the day of trial was a discovery violation. We reverse and remand for a new trial because the trial court did not conduct an adequate

Richardson

inquiry on the discovery violation, and we cannot conclude that the error was harmless.

The charge arose following a drive-by shooting incident. Witnesses Otis Ramsey and Jesse Ulcena (the victim), testified at trial. Ramsey knew of appellant from a youth football league. He admitted he had previously identified appellant as the shooter, but explained that he was only sixteen years old at the time, and was part of a group being interviewed by the police all at once. Someone in the group said, “I think it was Jarvis [appellant],” and Ramsey agreed. At trial, Ramsey insisted he did not know the shooter, and that he told this to the investigating police officer.

Ulcena said the car was within a few feet of him when he saw a hand emerge from the window holding a revolver. Ulce-na then saw the face of the gunman, who wore his hair in a “twists” hairstyle. The area was illuminated by a street light. Just as he saw the gun, Ulcena heard a single gunshot, turned and ran away. Two more gunshots fired. When Ulcena looked back, he saw the shooter’s face as the gun re-fired. When Ulcena went to run again, he felt a sharp pain in his back, causing him to fall to the ground.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.