Supreme Court of Louisiana October 1, 2010, 2010-CC-1561 (Batiste v. Bayou Steel Corp.)
Also known as
United States · · · 01-10-2010
PER CURIAM.
*
[ Kelvin Batiste was hired by Bayou Steel Corporation (“Bayou Steel”) in 1981,
*168
and assumed the position of First Helper in 1987. In this position, one of his primary responsibilities was installing new electrodes on the electrode arms of the No. 1 Furnace, a task he performed approximately 4,600 times over the next fourteen years. In August 2004, as he attempted to tighten an electrode while standing on the electrode arm, Mr. Batiste’s wrench slipped, causing him to lose his balance and fall thirty-five feet to the ground.
As a result of his accident and injuries, Mr. Batiste and his family filed the instant suit against Bayou Steel. Essentially, plaintiffs alleged Mr. Batiste’s accident was substantially certain to happen, and therefore fell within the intentional act exception to the workers’ compensation law set forth in La. R.S. 28:1032(B).
1
Bayou Steel filed a motion for summary judgment, arguing plaintiffs sole remedy was in workers’ compensation. In support of its motion, Bayou Steel ^produced evidence of Mr. Batiste and his co-workers having performed the same task on numerous occasions without incident.
The district court denied Bayou Steel’s motion for summary judgment. Bayou Steel applied for supervisory review of this ruling. The court of appeal denied the writ. This application followed.
In order to recover in tort against Bayou Steel under La. R.S. 28:1032(B), plaintiffs must prove Mr. Batiste’s injury resulted from an “intentional act.” In
Bazley v. Tortorich,
397 So.2d 475 (La.1981), we explained an intentional act requires the actor to either 1) consciously desire the physical result of his act, whatever the likelihood of that result happening from his conduct; or (2) know that the result is substantially certain to follow from his conduct, whatever his desire may be as to that result. In the instant case, plaintiffs do not allege Bayou Steel consciously desired to cause harm to Mr. Batiste. Rather, they assert Mr.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit