Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas May 26, 2010, AP-76,264 (Benavides, Ex Parte Jesse)
Also known as
United States · · · 26-05-2010
IN THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TEXAS No. AP-76,264 EX PARTE JESSE BENAVIDES, Applicant ON APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS IN CAUSE NO. 2001-CR-0493-W1 FROM THE 187TH JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT BEXAR COUNTY Holcomb, J., filed a dissenting opinion. I respectfully dissent. After reading the record carefully, I conclude that we should accept the trial court's recommendation to grant relief. The record supports the trial court's finding that Irma Pennington's habeas testimony was, in relevant part, "credible and believable" and "persuasive." The record also supports the trial court's conclusion that, in light of this newly discovered evidence, no reasonable juror could have convicted Jesse Benavides of the charge contained in the indictment. Allow me to review the basic facts, as they are reflected in the record. On March 22, 2000, Pennington gave a sworn statement to the Bexar County Sheriff's Office in which she claimed that Benavides "assaulted" her in her home on May 11, 1999. Penningon described the "assault," in relevant part, as follows: "He sat down next to me [on her couch] and he got really close and started touching my chest and putting his hand down my pants and I didn't fight. "I am [a] disabled Army nurse and I remember always telling my patients and their family [sic] that women should not resist rape and the injuries would be minimal. It was very difficult to not do anything but I didn't resist. "The thing [sic] I didn't want to make him mad and the thing I said nicely was I don't feel very comfortable with the things that he was doing. He asked where the bed was and he held my hand and took me to the bed that is next to the living room. He took my clothes off, he only unzipped his pants and brought them down a bit to about his knees and introduced his penis into my vagina and did not stay very long. I do not known [sic] if he finished because I don't have sensation on my right side even on the inside." (Some capitalization omitted.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit