Texas Court of Appeals, 3rd District (Austin) August 4, 2010, 03-09-00207-CV (J. Stephen Spencer v. Jonathan M. Gilbert)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-08-2010

TEXAS COURT OF APPEALS, THIRD DISTRICT, AT AUSTIN

NO. 03-09-00207-CV

J. Stephen Spencer, Appellant

v.

Jonathan M. Gilbert, Appellee

FROM COUNTY COURT OF BLANCO COUNTY

NO. 402, HONORABLE BILL GUTHRIE, JUDGE PRESIDING

MEMORANDUM OPINION

J. Stephen Spencer appeals the trial court’s judgment in a trial de novo review of a

judgment by the justice court in a forcible entry and detainer case. The trial court found that lessor

Jonathan M. Gilbert was entitled to possession of the house, and also ordered lessee Spencer to pay

Gilbert monetary damages suffered during Spencer’s withholding of the premises before judgment

and pending appellate review. Because Spencer has vacated the premises, there is no controversy

regarding possession of the property. Without addressing moot issues, we affirm the judgment.

Gilbert filed this forcible entry and detainer action in September 2008 to

evict Spencer, his tenant. Midway through trial at the justice court, Spencer sought to recuse

Justice of the Peace Terry Carter. JP Carter allegedly consulted with Justice of the Peace H.R. Riley

in Blanco County concerning his availability to hear the case, then recused himself, and referred the

case to JP Riley. After Spencer pointed out that recusal strips judges of their power over the case,

JP Carter signed a new order that simply recused himself. JP Riley held a trial in November 2008,

finding that Gilbert had the right to possession and ordering that Gilbert recover $4,650 from

Spencer as rent. Spencer filed a notice of appeal.

After a trial de novo in the county court—held on February 3, 2009, without

Spencer’s presence because, he asserts in his brief, he was unable to attend due to inclement weather

while he was on business out of state—the county court awarded possession to Gilbert and ordered

that Gilbert recover $9,300 from Spencer as damages for his withholding of the property, plus $200

in late fees.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.