Texas Court of Appeals, 12th District (Tyler) January 29, 2010, 12-08-00084-CV (Thomas Lee Fitzpatrick and Wife Jennifer Fitzpatrick v. David G. Watson, M.D.)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-01-2010

NO. 12-08-00084-CV

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS

TWELFTH COURT OF APPEALS DISTRICT

TYLER, TEXAS

THOMAS LEE FITZPATRICK AND § APPEAL FROM THE

WIFE, JENNIFER FITZPATRICK,

APPELLANTS

V. § COUNTY COURT AT LAW #3

DAVID G. WATSON, M.D.,

APPELLEE § SMITH COUNTY, TEXAS

MEMORANDUM OPINION

Thomas Lee Fitzpatrick and Jennifer Fitzpatrick appeal the trial court’s final judgment in

a medical malpractice lawsuit they brought against David G. Watson, a former physician. In two

issues, the Fitzpatricks argue that the trial court reversibly erred by excluding evidence that

Watson had a history of cocaine use and was suffering from cocaine induced impairment at the

time he treated Thomas Fitzpatrick’s injured arm. We affirm.

BACKGROUND

On July 6, 2002, Thomas Fitzpatrick accidentally broke through a glass window with his

arm, resulting in a severe cut to the arm. His wife, Jennifer Fitzpatrick, immediately drove him

to the emergency department of East Texas Medical Center (ETMC) in Tyler, Texas. At ETMC,

Watson examined and treated Fitzpatrick. At the time, Watson was a licensed, board certified

emergency medicine physician.

Watson examined Fitzpatrick, partially cleaned his wound, and sutured the wound closed.

Watson subsequently ordered that Fitzpatrick be discharged with instructions to follow up with

an orthopedic surgeon. He also prescribed pain medication for Fitzpatrick to take until he was

able to be treated further by the surgeon.

The following day, after experiencing intense pain in his arm, Fitzpatrick was taken by

his wife to Parkland Hospital in Dallas, Texas. An x-ray of Fitzpatrick’s arm was made, which

showed a foreign object in the arm. Parkland physicians determined that Fitzpatrick’s ulnar

nerve had been cut. Two days later, surgeons removed the foreign object, a glass shard, from

Fitzpatrick’s arm and attempted to repair the damage to his ulnar nerve. This repair attempt was

only partially successful; Fitzpatrick now suffers from a permanent loss of use in his hand.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.