Texas Court of Appeals, 8th District (El Paso) December 15, 2010, 08-09-00120-CV (Lilia v. Mendoza v. Victor M. Ramirez, Santiago Ramirez, Jr., Oswaldo H. Ramirez, Jr., Xavier Ramirez, Ramirez Mineral Trust, and Villarreal/Zapata)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-12-2010

COURT OF APPEALS

EIGHTH DISTRICT OF TEXAS

EL PASO, TEXAS

LILIA V. MENDOZA, §

Appellant, §

No. 08-09-00120-CV

v. §

Appeal from the

§

VICTOR M. RAMIREZ, SANTIAGO 49th Judicial District Court

RAMIREZ, JR., OSWALDO H. §

RAMIREZ, JR., AND XAVIER of Zapata County, Texas

RAMIREZ As Co-Trustees For The §

RAMIREZ MINERAL TRUST, AND (TC# 3342)

VILLAREAL/ZAPATA, §

Appellees. §

OPINION

Appellant, Lilia Mendoza, appeals the trial court’s grant of summary judgment in favor of

Appellees, Victor M. Ramirez, et al, otherwise known as the Ramirez Mineral Trust (“RMT”),

with respect to the title to the B-2 tract. On appeal, Ms. Mendoza argues the trial court erred

because res judicata elements were not satisfied for a grant of summary judgment based on a

prior federal condemnation proceeding, and even if RMT or its predecessors acquired title to the

tract, genuine issues of material fact exist as to whether Ms. Mendoza and the Villarreal family

later acquired title to the property through adverse possession. We affirm.

In 1994, RMT filed an action in a Zapata County trial court against Enron Oil & Gas

Company (“Enron”), Fidel Villarreal and Andrea Villarreal, J. Juventino Zapata and Alejandra V.

Zapata, Lilia V. Mendoza, and Roberto Villarreal and Aminta Villarreal (“the

Villarreal/Zapatas”). RMT’s claims against Enron were for unlawful trespass onto RMT’s

property, unlawful drainage, unjust enrichment, damages, and attorneys’ fees. RMT’s claims

against the Villarreal/Zapatas were to remove cloud on their title, quiet their title, and for trespass

to try title and damages. Ms. Mendoza filed counterclaims and cross-claims to assert that she

held title to the disputed property, as an heir of Mr. Olegario Villarreal, under various applicable

adverse possession statutes. Villarreal/Zapatas later intervened also asserting claims of adverse

possession. The five tracts in dispute at trial were Z-294.5 B-1 (the “B-1” tract), Z-294.5 B-2

(the “B-2” tract), Z-294.5 F-1 (the “F-1” tract), Z-294.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.