Washington Supreme Court October 7, 2010, No. 82950-1 (Forbes v. American Building Maintenance Co. West)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-10-2010

C. Johnson, J.

¶1 This case asks us to make two determinations regarding this lengthy attorney fee dispute. We must decide whether the trial court properly awarded prejudgment interest and whether the attorney’s contingency fee should have been based on the satisfaction of judgment amount rather than the settlement amount. The trial court awarded prejudgment interest and calculated the contingency fee from the settlement amount, and the Court of Appeals affirmed the award of prejudgment interest but modified the amount used to calculate the contingency fee, basing it instead on the satisfied judgment amount. We reverse the Court of Appeals on the modification, affirm the award of prejudgment interest, and reinstate the trial court’s order in all other respects.

Factual and Procedural History

¶2 This attorney fee dispute arose between petitioner Cheryl Forbes and her former attorney, respondent Mary *161Schultz. In the underlying case, Forbes brought an employment discrimination action against American Building Maintenance Company West and ABM Industries Inc. (collectively ABM). Unsatisfied with her original attorney’s performance, Forbes asked Schultz to represent her in the action.1

¶3 On February 19, 2001, Schultz agreed to take the case, and shortly thereafter she and Forbes executed a hybrid contingency fee agreement under which Schultz would receive a contingency fee plus an hourly rate, plus prevailing party fees and any outstanding costs. The contingency fee was to be 33 lA percent of any settlement amount and 40 percent of any post trial judgment. Forbes was to pay costs as they were incurred.

¶4 As the case proceeded, Forbes became delinquent on costs and fees. As a result, in May 2002, Forbes and Schultz orally agreed to a new fee arrangement under which Schultz would advance funds to pay for costs, and Forbes would use her best efforts to pay for costs as they accrued. Schultz also waived past defaults on the hourly fees owed.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.