Court of Appeals of Washington August 3, 2010, No. 40104-5-II (Chinn v. City of Spokane)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-08-2010

Bridgewater, J.

¶1 West Central Development LLC (West) appeals the superior court’s decision to grant Brad Chinn’s land use petition. Chinn filed the petition because he disagreed with the Spokane City Council’s (Council) decision to grant West a rezone. We hold that the Council misinterpreted the law in concluding that the rezone would not change the underlying land use. We further hold that the Council erroneously applied the law to the facts. We reverse the Council’s decision and reinstate the hearing examiner’s decision consistent with this opinion.

FACTS

¶2 West applied to rezone a block, consisting of eight city lots (Property) in Spokane, Washington, from “Office” to “Office Retail.”1 Certified Appeal Board Record (CABR) § 1, at 9; Spokane Municipal Code (SMC) 17C. 120.030(A), (B). Except for the county courthouse,2 which borders the Property’s eastern boundary, the land surrounding the Property is zoned Office and is developed with small scale offices, many of which are in former residences.

¶3 After West applied for the rezone, the city planning services recommended that the hearing examiner approve West’s rezone application with certain conditions. During the comment period before the hearing, several neighboring landowners, including Chinn, wrote letters opposing the rezone.

*297¶4 The hearing examiner denied West’s rezone application. The hearing examiner concluded that because Office Retail is a higher intensity office use and because the Property was not within a city center, the rezone was inconsistent with the Spokane comprehensive plan policy of directing higher intensity office uses to centers.

¶5 West appealed to the Council, which reversed the hearing examiner and approved West’s rezone application. The Council found that the comprehensive plan permitted office uses outside of a center if the use was within the boundaries of existing office designations.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.