District Court of Appeal of Florida May 12, 2010, No. 4D08-4474 (Department of Agriculture & Consumer Services v. Bogorff)
Also known as
United States · · · 12-05-2010
lead-opinion
FARMER, J.
The Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services (DACS) appeals a final judgment in favor of a class of more than 50,000 owners of healthy citrus trees in Broward County cut down and destroyed by DACS as part of its citrus canker eradication program (CCEP).1 *87The trial judge found that over 100,000 non-commercial trees in the County not affected with citrus canker had been taken and destroyed by DACS during the covered period, that the taking was for a public purpose, and that the owners of these residential trees were entitled to just and fair compensation for their healthy trees. A jury then found that just compensation for the class was $11,531,463. After applying certain setoffs and adding pre-judgment interest, the court entered judgment against DACS and the State of Florida in the amount of $8,043,542.
On appeal, DACS essentially argues:
A. The trial court improperly rejected its evidence in favor of the evidence offered by the plaintiff class.
B. No inverse condemnation was shown because the trees lacked any compensable value, citrus canker being deemed a public nuisance as a matter of law, and the trial court applied the wrong test for determining whether there had been a taking.
C. The legislature has abolished any common law claim of inverse condemnation and replaced it with a statutory claim.
D. The court applied the wrong measure of damages for the healthy trees destroyed in the CCEP.
E. No pre-judgment interest is allowed in this case.
There is no merit in any of these arguments.
A. Whose evidence and science was more reliable and credible?
When the contention is that the trier of fact has rejected what a party believes is the better evidence, both lay and expert, the supreme court has explained:
“It is clear that the function of the trial court is to evaluate and weigh the testimony and evidence based upon its observation of the bearing, demeanor and credibility of the witnesses appearing in the cause.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit