District Court of Appeal of Florida August 11, 2010, No. 4D08-4619 (Diaz v. State)
Also known as
United States · · · 11-08-2010
FISHMAN, JANE D., Associate Judge.
Manuel Diaz appeals his conviction and sentence of one count of lewd and lascivious battery. We reverse and remand for a new trial, because the trial court erroneously denied Diaz’ challenge for cause to a potential juror.
During voir dire the assistant state attorney had the following exchange with a potential juror:
STATE: You take that oath. And when you take that oath, those of us who are involved in the case count on you to, to uphold that oath. Okay? And you’re taking an oath to follow the law. [D]o you think that it would be, think you would cheat justice if you didn’t follow the law?
Prospective Juror: No. You have to listen to Judge’s instructions and not form your own opinions.
STATE: Okay. And if, if, what if the Judge gave you an instruction on the law and you didn’t agree with it? Your own personal feeling is I don’t think the law should be that way but the Judge says it is.
Prospective Juror: Well, I would, I guess I could be impartial, yes.
STATE: Okay.
Counsel for Mr. Diaz followed up with the juror, who explained that she had previously sat as a juror and heard evidence in several cases, including a rape case, but that those cases had terminated before deliberations. The following exchange then took place:
DEFENSE: Okay. Something happened that you weren’t privy to, but you were dismissed.
*34Prospective Juror: Exactly.
DEFENSE: Which, which is another important factor that I wanted to bring out. Do you understand the Judge is going to instruct you on the law and the law in a case like this will probably be handed to you to go to deliberate with so you can read the law and apply it to the facts and to the evidence so that you, you’re not expected to have that knowledge until you get in there. All right? And throughout the trial, [the State] was bringing up the point that the attorneys are going to be talking.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit