Supreme Judicial Court of Maine July 15, 2010 (Tibbetts v. Dairyland Insurance Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-07-2010

SILVER, J.

[¶ 1] Gary Tibbetts appeals from a judgment entered in the Superior Court (Penobscot County, Murphy, J.) following a jury trial that awarded him damages for injuries stemming from a motor vehicle collision. The issues we address on appeal involve the payment of underinsured motorist insurance. Dairyland Insurance Co. cross-appeals in part because it contests the allocation of payment among the un-derinsured motorist insurance carriers. This is an issue requiring clarification, and we discuss it below. We affirm the judgment except as to the award of medical payments benefits pursuant to Count III, which is vacated.

I. FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

[¶ 2] Tibbetts was injured on June 15, 2006, when the motorcycle he was operating collided with a car. Tibbetts owned a motorcycle repair business and had taken a customer’s motorcycle home that evening, extending his ride because of the nice weather. Tibbetts testified that repairs that he planned to do the next morning would require that the motorcycle have a warm engine. During his ride, a car pulled out in front of Tibbetts, causing an accident that resulted in serious injuries to him.

[¶ 3] The driver’s insurance company paid Tibbetts the full limits of its liability coverage, $100,000. Tibbetts initiated this action to collect his remaining damages under various uninsured/underinsured motorist (UM) policies.1 The jury returned a verdict for Tibbetts awarding $325,000 in total damages. The jury specifically found that Tibbetts’s use of the motorcycle, which the parties stipulated constituted a test drive, had been with permission of the owner.

[¶ 4] Five insurance policies potentially provide UM coverage for Tibbetts. Dairy-land had issued three motorcycle insurance policies: to Clark, the owner of the motorcycle; to Tibbetts; and to Tibbetts’s girlfriend and business partner in a policy that included Tibbetts as an insured. MMG Insurance Company had issued an automobile policy covering Tibbetts.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.