Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania September 23, 2010 (Thornton v. Philadelphia Housing Authority)
Also known as
United States · · · 23-09-2010
lead-opinion
OPINION BY
Judge McGINLEY.
In this interlocutory appeal by permission,1 the Philadelphia Housing Authority (PHA)2 and the administratrix and personal representative (Plaintiff) of the estate of decedent Nance appeal the October 24, 2008, Order of the Court of Common Pleas of Philadelphia County (trial court) which denied the parties’ cross-motions for summary judgment on the issue whether Plaintiffs claims are barred by sovereign immunity.3
Factual Background
On October 7, 2004, a three-alarm fire occurred at Plymouth Hall, a four story, 70-unit apartment building for senior citizens with low to moderate income located in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Plymouth Hall is owned and operated by the PHA. The fire, smoke and soot contributed to injuries of many of the tenants and the deaths of three tenants: Nance, Henrietta Alston and Geraldine Thornton.
The common hallway of the premises contained an automatic four zone fire alarm system equipped with audible horns and strobe warning devices. According to the expert report of Sure Guard, NFPA *1146[National Fire Protection Association] standards require “a minimum of 70 decibels at the pillow within a bedroom area.” Report of Sure Guard, May 1, 2008 (Sure-Guard Expert Report), at 8; R.R. at 629a. Prior to the fire, Zone # 1 of the fire alarm system was disconnected or bypassed by a PHA employee leaving 53 heat detectors, or 50% of the first floor heat detection system nonfunctional. As a result, the heat detector circuit in Nance’s apartment failed, activation of the main fire alarm system was delayed, and the tenants were not timely warned. Sure Guard Expert Report at 22; R.R. at 643a. Because Plymouth Hall did not have fire stops installed above the suspended ceilings nothing prevented the spread of fire and smoke between apartments. However, each individual apartment was equipped with a smoke detector.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit