Court of Chancery of Delaware September 20, 2010, C.A. No. 5074-VCL (Aveta Inc. v. Cavallieri)
Also known as
United States · · · 20-09-2010
OPINION
LASTER, Vice Chancellor.
In 2006, Aveta Inc. closed the acquisition of Preferred Medicare Choice Inc. (“PMC”), a Puerto Rico corporation. Ave-ta purchased PMC’s Class A shares from its controlling shareholders for 60.93% of the aggregate consideration, then merged a Puerto Rico acquisition subsidiary into PMC. PMC’s non-controlling Class B shares were converted into the right to receive the remaining 39.07% of the consideration. Part of the consideration was paid at closing, subject to post-closing adjustments, with the potential for an earn-out. Aveta would calculate the adjustments and earn-out, then attempt to reach agreement with Roberto L. Bengoa, who was designated in the transaction agreement as the “Shareholders’ Representative.” If they agreed, then payments would be made using their calculations. If not, then Ernst & Young LLP (“E & Y”) would resolve any disputes and make the determinations.
In June 2007, some 110 former PMC shareholders purported to revoke Bengoa’s *163authority as Shareholders’ Representative. Twenty-five former PMC shareholders have attempted to litigate the consideration and related issues in Puerto Rico. The Puerto Rico litigation has been stayed pending the outcome of this proceeding.
The central question in this case is whether the contractual process for calculating the consideration, including the outcome of the E & Y arbitration, binds all former PMC shareholders. The parties have cross moved for summary judgment.
The controlling and non-controlling shareholders are differently situated. The controlling shareholders signed the transaction agreement and bound themselves to its terms. As to them, agency law controls. They appointed Bengoa irrevocably as their representative and selected Delaware law to govern the relationship. They are bound by Bengoa’s acts.
None of the non-controlling shareholders signed the transaction agreement.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit