California Court of Appeal September 3, 2010, No. H034019 (Manson v. Shepherd)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-09-2010

*1247Opinion

BAMATTRE-MANOUKIAN, Acting P. J.

L INTRODUCTION

After the death of her husband, Maynard F. Manson, appellant Carol C. Manson became the sole trustee of the Maynard F. Manson and Carol C. Manson Revocable Living Trust (the Trust).1 In addition to being the trustee and the sole income beneficiary of the Trust, Carol is the president of the Trust’s primary asset, Wave Crest Development, Inc. (Wave Crest), and the chair of Wave Crest’s board of directors. The Trust owns 100 percent of Wave Crest’s shares, which Carol votes. During her administration of the Trust, Carol submitted a trustee’s petition for settlement of first account and report and approval of attorney fees. Respondents, who are Maynard’s four daughters from a prior marriage and remainder beneficiaries of the trust, objected to the petition.

After a court trial, the trial court issued a February 9, 2009 order approving the trustee’s accounting, with two exceptions. One exception is the subject of Carol’s appeal. She contends that the trial court misinterpreted Probate Code section 16350, subdivision (d)(1)(A)2 when it allocated to principal, rather than income, a $3 million dividend paid by Wave Crest to the Trust. On cross-appeal, respondents challenge the trial court’s approval of the trustee’s allocation to principal of a charge for $39,293.63 in expenses, a charge for $122,878.16 in interest on the trustee’s personal loan to the Trust, and a charge for attorney fees that respondents contend were unrelated to Trust administration.

After carefully reviewing the parties’ contentions on appeal and cross-appeal, for the reasons stated below we will affirm the trial court’s order.

H. FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

A. The Trust

Maynard and Carol married on June 14, 1978. Their estate planning included a postnuptial agreement, dated May 25, 1995, that provided that all of their assets would be held as separate property.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.