California Court of Appeal November 30, 2010, No. H032619 (Golin v. Allenby)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-11-2010

*621Opinion

DUFFY, J.

Appellants Jeffrey R. Golin and Elsie Y. Golin (collectively, the Golins) appeal from the dismissal of this action after the trial court determined them to be vexatious litigants under Code of Civil Procedure section 391, subdivision (b)(2) and (3),1 and they failed to post a $500,000 bond to continue the litigation under sections 391.3 and 391.4. The Golins contend that the order must be reversed because it found them to be vexatious litigants even though they did not meet the statutory criteria for this finding. They further contend that the order must be reversed because it determined, without legal basis, that there was no reasonable probability of their prevailing in the action, a mandatory determination under section 391.1 before the court can require a vexatious litigant to furnish security. We conclude that the trial court did not abuse its discretion in finding the Golins to be vexatious litigants under section 391, subdivision (b)(3). But because nothing in the record supports the court’s conclusion that the Golins have no reasonable probability of prevailing in the action, or any part of it, we reverse the order of dismissal.

STATEMENT OF THE CASE

I. Factual Background2

A. Historical Facts

In 2001, the Golins’ daughter Nancy, a woman in her 30’s with developmental disabilities, was living in their care and custody, as she had all her life. In November of that year, Nancy was with her mother, Elsie, at Elsie’s studio in Palo Alto when Nancy wandered off.3 The Golins began looking for Nancy and called the authorities. But Nancy was not found until she returned on her own the next morning. On her return, police suggested that Nancy should be examined at Stanford Medical Center to ensure that no harm had come to her. And the incident triggered an investigation by authorities into Nancy’s living circumstances.

While in the hospital, Nancy was subjected to a Welfare and Institutions Code section 5150 psychiatric hold.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.