New York Supreme Court September 27, 2010 (DiPietro v. New York State Board of Elections)
Also known as
United States · · · 27-09-2010
OPINION OF THE COURT
Timothy J. Drury, J.
David J. DiPietro submitted a petition for the independent nomination for the Tea Party for the office of the New York State Senate for the 59th District. Three thousand valid signatures were required by statute to qualify to be on the ballot. The New York State Board of Elections (the Board) first found that, of the 4,675 signatures submitted, 2,098 were invalid, leaving a total of 2,577 valid signatures. Therefore, it determined that the petition was 423 signatures short of the statutory requirement. It then recomputed the numbers involved from the original staff worksheets and the figures on the summary tally sheets. It has now determined that there were 2,350 invalid signatures, leaving a total of 2,325 valid signatures. It has determined that the petition is short 675 signatures from the 3,000 signatures required. It has stated that it has not reexamined the signatures in any way, but has merely re-added the numbers set forth on the work and tally sheets.
Mr. DiPietro has challenged the Board’s actions in voiding his nominating petitions pursuant to Election Law § 16-102.
The Board invalidated over 400 signatures because the witnesses had previously signed a designating petition for the same office. The petitioner has argued that, in removing the requirement that a witness be also “qualified to sign the petition” (Election Law § 6-140 [2]) in 2009, the Legislature also removed the requirement that the witness not have previously signed a designating petition for the same office (see Matter of Sinagra v Hogan, 97 AD2d 643 [1983], affd 60 NY2d 811 [1983]).
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit