Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Alleghany County June 10, 2010, no. GD 07-7380 (Moats v. Grossman)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-06-2010
FRIEDMAN, J,
Defendants have filed four motions for summary judgment directed at four of the plaintiffs, Donna D. Miller, Rachel E. Miller, Jean F. Scott, and Dawn M. Stroncek, which are all based on the bar of the statute of limitations. Those plaintiffs responded that the discovery rule delayed the start date for the limitations period, and, after oral argument, the court permitted further briefing on the issue of whether plaintiffs had raised the discovery rule in their reply to defendants’ new matter. A few days later, plaintiffs’ attorney asked it, in lieu of briefing, they could present a petition to amend the complaint to expand on the factual basis for the applicability of the discovery rule. Because he had discussed this with counsel for the other side who did not object to the undersigned, rather than the calendar control judge, hearing the petition, we agreed and directed them to follow the same schedule as had been set for the briefing of the summary judgment motions.
In retrospect, we should not have agreed to this approach. An amendment to a complaint is not the way to address the statute of limitations issue, which is properly raised in new matter and countered by a reply to new *366matter. That has already been done here. The issue is whether or not the claim of the four plaintiffs named above are barred has been joined and can be dealt with. We therefore deny the petition for leave of court to file amended complaint.
In connection with the petition for leave to amend, it appears that both sides have already adequately briefed the issues related to the discovery rule and the facts each contends are material to that issue, so we will not require further briefs. However, before we issue our ruling on the four motions for summary judgment we will permit counsel to file any supplemental briefs no later than June 23, 2010. Both briefs are due at the same time and no further briefing will be permitted unless specifically requested by the court.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit