Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Philadelphia County August 11, 2010, no. 001750 (Carr v. Immaculate Mary Nursing Home)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-08-2010

MOSS, J.,

This matter concerns whether we erred in overruling defendants’ preliminary objections in the form of a motion to compel arbitration.

FACTS AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY

Plaintiff John Carr Jr. executor of the estate of John Carr Sr. commenced this action for negligence and wrongful death on January 15, 2010 against defendants Immaculate Mary Nursing Home, Catholic Healthcare Services of the Archdiocese of Philadelphia, and the Archdiocese of Philadelphia. Plaintiff alleges defendants failed to properly supervise Carr while he resided at Immaculate Mary Nursing Home Facility resulting in serious injuries leading to his death. (Complaint p. 8.) Carr was admitted on January 26, 2009 with symptoms of dementia including disorientation, confusion, decreased awareness, ambulatory deficits, impaired vision, and incontinence. (Complaint pp. 8-9.) Carr had a history of falling. Id. The facility offered a dementia program to “maintain optimum comfort and provide the highest quality of life possibly for resident with late stage dementia.” (Complaint p. 7.) Residents would be housed on a secure dementia floor. Id.

On admission, Carr’s wife executed a nursing facility admission agreement containing a binding, mandatory arbitration clause. (Admission agreement pp. 17-21.) Paragraph 1 of the agreement stated:

*418“This agreement is made by and between Immaculate Mary Home (facility), a Pennsylvania no-profit corporation and resident and his/her legal representative and or/ the individual who has access to resident’s income and financial resources available to pay for nursing care (responsible person) for the provision of nursing services for John Carr (resident).”

The agreement defined “responsible person” as follows:

“Whereas, the responsible person may be the guardian, the agent under a valid power of attorney, or any person authorized by resident to serve as resident’s responsible person.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.