Massachusetts Appeals Court May 13, 2010, No. 08-P-1963 (Commonwealth v. Humphries)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-05-2010

lead-opinion

Cypher, J.

The defendant, Jerold Humphries, seeks to overturn two drug offense convictions,1 claiming that his motion for a required finding of not guilty after the Commonwealth’s case in chief should have been allowed. We conclude that the evidence of constructive possession was insufficient to support his conviction and we reverse.2

*703Facts.3 A Boston police detective testified that the police executed a search warrant for an apartment at 15 Wentworth Street, in the Dorchester section of Boston, on November 15, 2003. They seized “crack” cocaine and marijuana in a back bedroom where two men were hiding in a closet, and another was “at the end of the bed.” None of the three had any personal effects in the room. The defendant was not in the apartment.

In another bedroom, furnished only with a futon bed, police seized sixteen small plastic bags of marijuana in one large bag, eight larger individually wrapped bags of marijuana in another large bag, “Glad plastic bags” and small bags printed with an “apple.” No one was present in the room. The police also found a Massachusetts identification card with the defendant’s name and picture, and an envelope addressed to him at a different address which had been postmarked on October 27, 2003. The defendant’s address on the identification card was 49 Bullard Street, the same address as appeared on the envelope. No other personal effects of the defendant, or any personal effects of the three individuals observed in the rear bedroom were found in the vacant bedroom. The defendant was charged only for the marijuana found in the room where his identification was found.

Discussion. 1. The motion for a required finding of not guilty.4 The defendant argues that his motion for a required finding of not guilty should have been allowed because the evidence failed to link him with the marijuana found in the vacant bedroom.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.