Massachusetts Appeals Court October 18, 2010, No. 09-P-1258 (Apthorp v. OneBeacon Insurance Group, LLC)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-10-2010

Cohen, J.

In 1975, the Concord home of Helen S. Thompson was burglarized. Among the items stolen was a portrait that *116recently had been appraised by a Boston art dealer at $25,000, but that had unique value to Thompson and her family. The portrait was painted in Italy, in 1765, by the artist Angelica Kauffmann,3 and depicted Thompson’s ancestors, John Apthorp and his two daughters. It was considered a family heirloom.

At the time of the burglary, Thompson was insured under a homeowner’s policy issued by Northern Assurance Company (Northern), the predecessor in interest to the defendant, One-Beacon Insurance Group, LLC (OneBeacon). Among other things, the policy covered the loss of unscheduled personal property by theft, up to $32,500.

Thompson notified Northern of the burglary and submitted a document entitled “Claim and Affidavit,” to which she attached a descriptive list of the stolen articles. The list enumerated several paintings (including the portrait), decorative furnishings, sterling silver, and jewelry. For some, but not all of the items, Thompson also provided estimated values, which totaled $65,000. The portrait was the only item that had an appraisal to establish its value.

Northern acknowledged that the total value of the stolen items was no less than the policy limit of $32,500, and agreed to pay that amount. As required by Northern, Thompson executed a document entitled “Sworn Statement in Proof of Loss and Subrogation Agreement” (Subrogation Agreement), dated January 19,1977. The Subrogation Agreement recited that Thompson accepted the sum of $32,500 “in full release and satisfaction in compromise settlement” of her claim.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.