Supreme Court of New Hampshire December 22, 2010, No. 2009-047 (State v. Addison)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-12-2010

CONBOY, J.

The defendant, Michael Addison, was convicted by a jury of conspiracy to commit criminal threatening and reckless conduct. See RSA 629:3 (2007); RSA 631:4 (2007); RSA 626:8 (2007); RSÁ 631:3 (2007). He appeals, arguing that: (1) the Trial Court (McGuire, J.) erred by informing the jury venire that he had been separately charged with the murder of a police officer; and (2) the method used to select prospective grand and petit jurors did not comply with the requirement of RSA 500-A:6 (2010) that the juror selection process be “random.” We affirm.

I. Facts

The defendant was convicted of conspiracy to commit criminal threatening and reckless conduct arising out of his involvement in an incident where gunshots were fired at an apartment building on Roy Drive in Manchester.

The parties do not dispute that the shooting at Roy Drive occurred less than twenty-four hours before the murder of Manchester Police Officer *302Michael Briggs, for which the defendant was later indicted and convicted. See State v. Addison, 159 N.H. 87 (2009). The gun used in the Roy Drive shooting was the same weapon allegedly used to kill Officer Briggs. Widespread media coverage linked the defendant to the murder of Officer Briggs. The State subsequently used the defendant’s convictions in this case as aggravating factors to support the State’s request to seek the death penalty in the Briggs case.

II. VandeBogart Instruction

The defendant submitted proposed voir dire questions related to the extensive pre-trial publicity about the capital murder charge. The trial court found, however, that the defendant’s proposed questions “could create confusion and speculation among potential jurors and hinder the attempt to select fair and impartial jurors.” The court noted that the proposed questions “imply a connection between Officer Briggs’s death and the defendant without stating it. This would not serve the defendant’s apparent purpose not to inform the jury about the capital murder case.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.