Massachusetts Superior Court March 12, 2010, No. 080809D (Curry v. Great American Insurance)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-03-2010

Tucker, Richard T., J.

This Court has, in two previous rulings, set forth the facts and unique procedural manner in which this matter has progressed. By order of November 2, 2009, Justice James R. Lemire ordered that the lien of Great American Insurance Company (Great American) had not been eliminated by operation of G.L.c. 231, §60G, and ruled that the arbitration high/low agreement resulting in a $300,000 arbitration payment is a settlement for purposes of G.L.c. 152, §15. Judge Lemire ordered that a hearing “be scheduled to determine a fair allocation of settlement proceeds.”

After hearing and by Order of January 22, 2010 this Court ruled that the proposals for allocating settlement proceeds submitted by both the plaintiff and Great American were unacceptable and the parties were ordered to resubmit their proposals which “should more fairly and reasonably reflect the percentages of the settlement allocable to loss of net income, to which the lien may attach, and loss of consortium, to which it may not” [26 Mass. L. Rptr. 409). Thereafter the parties submitted additional allocation proposals.

This Court indicated in said order that “while a judge may only approve or disapprove of a settlement allocation, it is not allowed to impose his or her formula for the same.” Thus the Court either approves one of the proposed allocations or again declares both to be unacceptable.

Upon this background the Court approves the proposed allocation of the arbitration settlement amount of $300,000 submitted by the plaintiffs. In doing so, the Court rules that settlement proceeds representing payment for conscious pain and suffering of the deceased, the consortium damages paid to anon-dependent, Shaun Pietila, as well as consortium-like damages allocated to Deborah Pietila and awarded pursuant to G.L.c. 229, §2, are not subject to the lien of Great American.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.