Massachusetts Superior Court June 18, 2010, No. 092935 (Rutledge v. Chaprales)
Also known as
United States · · · 18-06-2010
Fremont-Smith, Thayer, J.
The plaintiff, George Rutledge (“Rutledge”), a resident of Weston, Massachusetts, is the duly appointed Personal Representative of the estate of Charles A. Chaprales (“Charles”), who died on February 9, 2009, and was his nephew. The defendants are Charles’ son Arthur and Arthur’s wife Ann. Plaintiff seeks a declaration that Charles’ estate is the rightful owner of real estate and of a yacht, which defendants assert is rightfully theirs.
The subject real estate is held by the C&V Real Estate Trust, of which Charles was the sole trustee and beneficiary. Arthur bases his claim to ownership on a purported July 1, 1999 “assignment of beneficial interest” wherein Charles stated “that I have previously assigned all my right, title and beneficial interest in the C&V Realty Trust to 1. Arthur C. Chaprales, d.o.b. 9/7/1953, ss# 022-42-3954.” Arthur further asserts that Charles orally promised him at that time that the property would be his only when Charles “closed his eyes,” i.e., died.
The authenticity of Charles’ 1999 purported assignment to Arthur may be questioned in light of Arthur’s denial under oath in his subsequent 2001 divorce proceedings that he possessed any documents evidencing any ownership interest in the Trust or in the real estate. (See answers to document requests.) The legal force of Charles’ alleged 1999 oral promise to Arthur is also problematic in view of the Statutes of Frauds and of Wills.
But, in any event, it is not controverted that Arthur made sworn statements in connection with his 2001 *221divorce wherein he denied that he had any beneficial interest in the real estate or the yacht.
Arthur also denied under oath any ownership interest in the real estate or the yacht in his November 2, 2001 answers to his then-wife Bonnie’s interrogatories filed in the divorce proceedings.
In answer to interrogatory No.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit