Massachusetts Superior Court July 15, 2010, No. 20101419 (Karasavas v. Gargano)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-07-2010

Fremont-Smith, Thayer, J.

Plaintiff has sued defendant Gargano to recover allegedly excessive attorney *363fees paid to Gargano for his representation of plaintiff, who had been charged with indecent assault and battery in the Quincy District court. On the day scheduled for trial, plaintiff admitted to sufficient facts, was found guilty, and was sentenced to two years of probation. For his services, Gargano had demanded, and was paid, $120,000.

Gargano has asserted a counterclaim not only against plaintiff but also asserted a separate claim against plaintiffs counsel in this lawsuit for violation of c. 93A in bringing this action. Plaintiff has moved to strike that part of the counterclaim.

The relevant question is whether a defendant can bring a counterclaim not only against a plaintiff but also against a non-party. As stated in Value Pharmacy, Inc. v. Mason, 1997 WL 1361144 (Mass.Super. 1997):

Mass.R.Civ.P. 13(a) and (b) provide that a party may bring a counterclaim against an opposing party. Mass.R.Civ.P. 13(h) supplements this rule and directs that “(p)ersons other than those made parties to the original action may be made parties to a counterclaim or cross-claim accordance with the provisions of Rule 19 & 20.” . . . Massachusetts case law does not delve beyond this straight forward language of 13(h). Conversely, federal courts have confronted similar situations to the one at hand when interpreting similarly worded Fed.RCiv.P. 13(h). “(A]bsent compelling reasons to the contrary or significant difference in content,” the Court should look to the interpretations of the federal rule. Shuman v. The Stanley Works, 30 Mass.App.Ct. 951, 953 (1991) (rescript).

Federal courts have allowed parties to assert claims against non-parties. See F.D.I.C. v. Bathgate, 27 F.3d 873-74 (3rd Cir. 1994) (allowing defendant’s counterclaim to include new party pursuant to Rule 13(h)); Various Markets, Inc. v. Chase Manhattan Bank, 908 F.Sup. 459, 471 (E.D.Mich. 1995).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.