Oregon Supreme Court August 5, 2010, Agency 07-AB-1130; CA A136061; SC S056569 (McDowell v. Employment Department)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-08-2010

*608

LINDER, J.

In this unemployment compensation case, the Employment Appeals Board (the board) concluded that claimant was not entitled to unemployment benefits because he voluntarily left work without good cause. Claimant, on judicial review of the board’s order, challenged that determination; the Court of Appeals affirmed.

McDowell v. Employment Dept.,

222 Or App 170, 193 P3d 989 (2008). As explained below, because we conclude that claimant voluntarily left work with good cause, we reverse the Court of Appeals decision and remand to the board.

The facts, as pertinent to the issues before us, are not challenged.

1

We therefore describe the facts consistently with those found by the board and the record that supports the board’s findings.

See Meltebeke v. Bureau of Labor and Industries,

322 Or 132, 134, 903 P2d 351 (1995) (where agency’s factual findings are not challenged, those findings are the facts for purposes of judicial review).

Claimant worked for employer, Klamath County School District, as a probationary first-year high school language arts and drama teacher. Less than six months into his job, claimant showed his senior English classes a 10-minute clip depicting a dramatic monologue from the film "Glengarry Glen Ross.” The clip, which contained some profanity, was intended as a lesson about language use and misuse. Showing that film clip to the class violated employer’s policy requiring preapproval by the school principal before teachers may show students films containing profanity. Employer, however, had not advised claimant of that policy and the policy was not contained in employer’s handbook.

As a result of claimant’s action in showing the film , clip, employer placed claimant on administrative leave. On

*609

February 19, 2007, the personnel director for the district informed claimant that he would be recommending claimant’s discharge at the upcoming school board meeting on March 9, 2007.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.