Arizona Supreme Court July 1, 2010, CR-08-0098-AP (State v. Villalobos)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-07-2010

SUPREME COURT OF ARIZONA

En Banc

STATE OF ARIZONA, ) Arizona Supreme Court

) No. CR-08-0098-AP

Appellee, )

) Maricopa County

v. ) Superior Court

) No. CR2004-005523-001

JOSHUA IDLEFONSO VILLALOBOS, )

)

Appellant. )

) O P I N I O N

__________________________________)

Appeal from the Superior Court in Maricopa County

The Honorable Raymond P. Lee, Judge

AFFIRMED

________________________________________________________________

TERRY GODDARD, ARIZONA ATTORNEY GENERAL Phoenix

By Kent E. Cattani, Chief Counsel,

Criminal Appeals/Capital Litigation Section

Jonathan Bass, Assistant Attorney General Tucson

Attorneys for State of Arizona

DROBAN & COMPANY, PC Anthem

By Kerrie M. Droban

Attorney for Joshua Idlefonso Villalobos

________________________________________________________________

H U R W I T Z, Vice Chief Justice

¶1 Joshua Idlefonso Villalobos was convicted of first

degree murder and child abuse and sentenced to death for the

murder. We have jurisdiction over this automatic appeal

pursuant to Article 6, Section 5(3) of the Arizona Constitution

and A.R.S. §§ 13-4031 and 13-4033(A)(1) (2010).

I. FACTS AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY1

¶2 Villalobos lived with Annette Verdugo, five-year-old

Ashley Molina (Verdugo’s daughter), and the couple’s two-year-

old daughter. On January 3, 2004, Villalobos and the children

picked Verdugo up at work and took her to dinner. Ashley did

not eat and complained about stomach pains. Villalobos and the

children again picked Verdugo up from work after her shift ended

in the early morning of January 4. When Verdugo noted an odd

smell, Villalobos claimed he had vomited in the car.

¶3 When they arrived home, Villalobos carried Ashley

upstairs and put her to bed. At approximately 7 a.m.,

Villalobos told Verdugo that Ashley was unresponsive. Ashley’s

body was cold and hard. Villalobos told Verdugo “they’re going

to think it’s me, I was the only one with her.”

¶4 After some delay, Villalobos and Verdugo took Ashley

to the hospital.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.