District Court, D. New Hampshire June 23, 2011, CV-10-264-PB (Milford-Bennington RR v. Pan Am)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-06-2011

Milford-Bennington RR v . Pan Am CV-10-264-PB 06/23/11

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE DISTRICT OF NEW HAMPSHIRE

Milford-Bennington Railroad Co.,

Inc. and Peter Leishman

v. Case No. 10-cv-264-PB

Opinion No. 2011 DNH 101

Pan Am Railways, Inc., Boston and

Maine Corporation, and Springfield

Terminal Railway Company

O R D E R

Milford-Bennington Railroad C o . (“MBR”) and its employee,

Peter Leishman, have sued Pan Am Railways, Inc., Boston and

Maine Corporation, and Springfield Terminal Railway

(collectively “Pan Am”) alleging breach of contract and breach

of good faith and fair dealing claims. Plaintiffs base their

causes of action on claimed breaches of the Trackage Rights

Agreement (“TRA”) that grants MBR the non-exclusive right to use

railroad tracks owned by Pan Am in Wilton and Milford, New

Hampshire.

Pan Am relied on the TRA in barring Leishman from using its

tracks after he was involved in an accident at a highway

crossing while operating an MBR train.1 According to Pan Am, it

was entitled to ban Leishman because he violated a Pan Am safety

rule that required him to either provide an on-ground warning at

the crossing or station a qualified employee at the crossing who

had the ability to communicate with the train.2

Plaintiffs argue that Pan Am violated the TRA when it

excluded Leishman from the tracks because: (1) Leishman did not

violate Pan Am’s safety rules; (2) Pan Am did not provide

Leishman with the procedural protections he was entitled to

under the TRA;3 and (3) the penalty that Pan Am imposed for

Leishman’s misconduct is excessive.

1 The provision of the TRA that Pan Am relied on provides that

“[Pan Am] shall have the right to exclude from the Trackage any

employee of MBR determined by [Pan Am] . . . to have violated

[Pan Am’s] rules, regulations, orders, practices, or

instructions.” Agreement, Doc. N o . 32-3, at 6.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.