Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania April 28, 2011, 269 M.D. 2001 (Considine v. Reliance Insurance)
Also known as
United States · · · 28-04-2011
MEMORANDUM OPINION
OPINION BY
LEADBETTER, President Judge.
KOT Insurance Company, a claimant against the Reliance Insurance Company (in Liquidation), objected to the Liquidator’s notice of determination on its claims and now takes exception to the recommended decision of the referee appointed by this Court to hear the objection. KOT asserts error in the referee’s conclusion that its claim was properly classified at priority level (e), as a claim under a policy of reinsurance, rather than (b), as a claim under a policy of direct insurance. Following consideration of the referee’s report, the exceptions and the Liquidator’s response, the exceptions are overruled, the referee’s recommendation is approved and his report, attached hereto, is adopted. The Liquidator’s notice of determination assigning priority (e) is affirmed.
There is no dispute that KOT is a captive insurance company created by Petról-eos Mexicanos (“Pemex”), Mexico’s state-owned petroleum company, for the purpose of covering the risks of its parent company. KOT insured the bulk of Pemex liability (97.5%) under a Multi-Peril Insurance Package Insurance Policy. KOT and Seguros Comercial America S.A. de C.V., the insurer assuming responsibility for the remaining 2.5% of liability, ceded the risk in excess of the first $40 million pursuant to a Multi-Peril Package Reinsurance Policy. Of the subscribing reinsurers assuming various portions of the risk, Reliance Insurance Company agreed to accept 10% of the ceded risk. Pemex sustained a loss in 1999, as a result of damage incurred during a tropical depression. At the time KOT filed its claim, Reliance had entered liquidation. The Liquidator determined the priority level of the claim to be (e) and KOT does not dispute that this is the appropriate priority level for a claim on a reinsurance contract.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit