Connecticut Appellate Court November 15, 2011, AC 32293 (McCarthy v. Cadlerock Properties Joint Venture, L.P.)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-11-2011

*112

Opinion

BORDEN, J.

The defendant, Cadlerock Properties Joint Venture, L.P., appeals from the judgment of the trial court ordering permanent injunctive relief that requires it to comply with a 1997 order of the plaintiff, Gina McCarthy, the former commissioner of environmental protection,

1

and assessing a civil penalty of $282,000

2

for noncompliance with that order.

3

The defendant claims that the court (1) improperly considered the liability and financial resources of nonparties in assessing a civil penalty and (2) failed to assess properly the defendant’s ability to pay a civil penalty.

4

We affirm the judgment of the trial court.

The following facts and procedural history are relevant to our resolution of the defendant’s appeal. The defendant is a limited partnership under the laws of Ohio with a principal place of business in Newton Falls, Ohio, and is not registered to do business in Connecticut. The general partner of the defendant is Cadlerock,

*113

Inc., an Ohio corporation. Daniel C. Cadle was the president of Cadlerock, Inc., until 2008, and is now the chairman of Cadlerock, Inc., and The Cadle Company. Cadle is also the sole shareholder of Cadlerock, Inc., and The Cadle Company. The defendant buys real estate and loans, obtains title to those properties and obtains financing from banks jointly with Cadlerock Joint Venture, L.P., an affiliated entity, whose general partner is also Cadlerock, Inc.

The defendant is the owner of 335 acres of real property located between 392 and 460 Squaw Hollow Road in the towns of Willington and Ashford. The defendant obtained ownership of the property by deed dated November 15, 1996, from an affiliated entity, Cadle Properties of Connecticut, Inc. That entity obtained ownership of the property on September 7, 1995, via a deed in lieu of foreclosure from Ashford Development Company in connection with a loan owed to Cadle Company of Connecticut, Inc., another affiliated entity.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.