Court of Appeals of Oregon June 22, 2011, C081586CR; A141053 (State v. Savastano)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-06-2011

*586

SCHUMAN, P. J.

Defendant was accused of embezzling hundreds of thousands of dollars from her employer in numerous individual theft transactions over a 16-month period in 2005 and 2006. The district attorney charged her with 10 counts of first-degree aggravated theft, ORS 164.057, and six counts of first-degree theft, ORS 164.055 (2007).

1

Each count represented the thefts that occurred within a named month. The counts charging aggravated theft alleged that, in a particular month, defendant stole money “with a total value of $10,000 and more,” while the counts charging theft alleged that, in a particular month, the amount was “$750 and more.” The prosecutor explained that he decided to aggregate the thefts as he did in this case in order to provide “a clear organizational outline for the jury.” Defendant appeals from a judgment of conviction entered after conditional guilty pleas, arguing that the prosecution did not have a consistent, systematic policy regarding aggregation and, for that reason, the aggregation in this case violated Article I, section 20, of the Oregon Constitution.

2

The state contends that the prosecutor’s decision was within his discretion. We agree with defendant, and we therefore reverse and remand.

Under ORS 164.055 (2007), a person commits first-degree theft if the total value of the stolen property “in a single or aggregate transaction is $750 or more.” The more serious crime of aggravated first-degree theft occurs if “[t]he value of the property in a single or aggregate transaction is $10,000 or more.” ORS 164.057(l)(b). “Aggregated” transactions are governed by ORS 164.115(5):

“The value of single theft transactions may be added together if the thefts were committed:

*

*

* *

*587

“(b) Against the same victim, or two or more persons who are joint owners, within a 180-day period.”

In the present case, defendant was charged with a large number of thefts, some as small as $50, against the same victim, occurring over a period of 16 months.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.