Court of Appeals of Kansas June 17, 2011, 102,724 (State v. Dillon)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-06-2011

Leben, J.:

We revisit this case on remand from the Kansas Supreme Court. Previously, we had vacated the district court’s sentence of Wilham Dillon based on our conclusion that the district court explicitly refused to consider the arguments upon which Dillon sought a departure sentence.

State v. Dillon,

44 Kan. App. 2d 1138, 244 P.3d 680 (2010). A majority of this panel concluded that the district court’s refusal to consider relevant factual arguments the defendant made in support of a departure sentence violated the defendant’s due-process rights. Because of that, we concluded that an appeal could be heard despite the normal rule that a defendant may not appeal a departure sentence.

The Kansas Supreme Court summarily reversed our decision and remanded for further consideration in light of

State v. Huerta,

291 Kan. 831, 247 P.3d 1043 (2011). Having considered supplemental briefs from the parties and

Huerta,

we now dismiss Dillon’s appeal for lack of jurisdiction.

As all parties recognize, the district court gave Dillon a presumptive sentence: sentencing guidelines called for a prison sentence, not probation, and the court gave Dillon a sentence within the range called for by the guidelines. And the legislature has pro

*1076

vided in K.S.A. 21-4721(c)(1) that an “appellate court shall not review . . . [a]ny sentence that is within the presumptive sentence for the crime.” This restriction is important because the right to appeal in Kansas is limited to what is provided by statute; Kansas courts have not recognized any constitutional right to an appeal.

State v. Gill,

287 Kan. 289, 293-94, 196 P.3d 369 (2008).

Before

Huerta,

the panel majority had understood that there was a limited exception when the district court denied due process to the defendant at sentencing. But in the

Huerta

decision, rendered 4 months after our first decision in Dillon’s case, our Supreme Court said that we had overextended the cases suggesting exceptions. 291 Kan. at 839-40.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.