Court of Appeals of Oregon July 27, 2011, 091455E2; A144157 (Scott v. Jackson County)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-07-2011

*486

WOLLHEIM, J.

Plaintiff conducted a rabbit breeding operation on property located in Jackson County. In 2001, plaintiff pleaded no contest to animal abuse, and, in conjunction with the criminal proceedings, the county seized her rabbits. The county housed, treated, and fed the rabbits before declaring them abandoned, at which point the county gave them away. In 2003, plaintiff filed an action against the county in federal court, alleging civil rights violations and common-law tort claims. After the Ninth Circuit affirmed summary judgment as to some of plaintiffs claims, she filed a complaint in state court based on the same factual allegations. The trial court granted the county’s motion for summary judgment based on issue preclusion, and plaintiff now appeals that judgment. We reverse and remand.

This much is undisputed. In May 2001, animal control officers investigated a complaint about the condition of plaintiffs rabbits. The officers discovered and seized four dead rabbits, and plaintiff was charged with animal neglect. In August 2001, county officials executed a search warrant on plaintiffs property and seized approximately 300 rabbits; they left some 300 additional rabbits on the property. Plaintiff subsequently pleaded no contest to one count of animal neglect, and she was sentenced to probation. The sentence, however, also prohibited plaintiff from possessing animals and ordered that she forfeit her remaining rabbits.

The county seized the remaining rabbits immediately after plaintiffs sentence was pronounced. Two weeks later, the sentencing judge reconsidered the conditions of her order. The judge deleted the forfeiture provision but left in place the condition that plaintiff not possess any animals. Plaintiff thereafter sought the return of the rabbits that were in the county’s custody, but the county refused to return them (ostensibly because plaintiff still could not herself

possess

them).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.