District Court, D. Rhode Island March 31, 2011, C.A. 09-527-ML (Rhode Island Hospitality Ass'n v. City of Providence Ex Rel. Lombardi)
Also known as
United States · · · 31-03-2011
MEMORANDUM AND ORDER
MARY M. LISI, Chief Judge.
The plaintiffs in this litigation are a Rhode Island trade group (the “Association”) related to the food service, lodging, restaurant, and tourism industry in Rhode Island,
1
and two privately held real estate investment limited partnerships organized in Delaware: PRI I, L.P. (the “Hilton”), which owns and operates the Hilton Providence, a 274 room hotel in Providence that includes “Shula’s 347” restaurant; and PRI XVIII, L.P. (“The Westin”), which owns and operates The Westin Providence, a 564 room hotel that includes the “Centro” restaurant.
The plaintiffs seek to enjoin the enforcement of municipal ordinance Section 2-18.5 (the “Ordinance”), titled “Hospitality Business Protection and Worker Retention”, which was enacted by the City of Providence (the “City”) on October 21, 2010 and made retroactively effective to October 26, 2009 with respect to some, but not all, of the affected businesses. The Ordinance sets forth various requirements regarding “the retention of hospitality employees when ownership or management of hospitality businesses change.” Ordinance Preamble.
The parties have submitted an agreed statement of facts (“SOF”) and have stipulated that the Court will decide the case on its merits based on that submission. SOF, Docket No. 44; February 18, 2010 Order. Two related service worker unions, a group of hospitality employees, and several community organizations (collectively, the
“amici
”) have filed an
amicus curiae
brief. The Court conducted two separate hearings at which counsel for both parties and the
amici
supported their respective position with oral arguments and addressed questions posed by the Court.
I. Factual Background and Procedural History
An earlier version of the Ordinance (the “First Ordinance”) was enacted by the City on October 15, 2009. SOF 7.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit