Texas Court of Appeals, 1st District (Houston) November 17, 2011, 01-10-00668-CV (Westside Wrecker Service, Inc. v. Patricia Davis Skafi D/B/A Master Auto Body Shop and D/B/A North Loop Towing and Dwight Cannon D/B/A D.C. Wrecker)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-11-2011

OPINION

HARVEY BROWN, Justice.

Westside Wrecker Service, Inc. challenges the trial court’s judgment awarding damages for unpaid storage and towing fees to Patricia Davis Skafi, d/b/a Master Auto Body Shop and d/b/a North Loop Towing, and Dwight Cannon, d/b/a D.C. Wrecker. A jury found that Westside breached an oral contract with Skafi and Cannon, the parties had formed a partnership, and Westside breached various partnership duties to Skafi and Cannon. The trial court disregarded the jury’s liability findings on breach of contract and partnership duties, as well as some of the jury’s damages findings, but it entered judgment for Skafi and Cannon for unpaid towing and storage fees and attorney’s fees.

In six issues, Westside contends that the trial court erred by awarding damages in the absence of a liability finding; there is no evidence to support Skafi and Cannon’s damages; and challenges the trial court’s award of attorney’s fees. In five issues, Skafi and Cannon contend that the trial court erred in disregarding the jury’s finding that Westside had failed to comply with its agreement “to timely pay for storage and free tows” performed by Skafi and Cannon because the statute of frauds does not bar enforcement of the parties’ oral agreement; the trial court erred in granting judgment notwithstanding the verdict because the jury’s partnership finding was supported by legally sufficient evidence of the statutory partnership factors and the statute of frauds does not apply to the jury’s partnership finding; “[i]f the jury’s

*157

partnership finding is reinstated on appeal, this case should [be] remand[ed] for an accounting of Mr. Cannon’s partnership damages”; and respond to Westside’s challenges to the damages and attorney’s fees awarded.

We reverse the trial court’s judgment with respect to Westside,

1

and enter judgment that Skafi and Cannon take nothing on their claims against Westside.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.