California Court of Appeal April 27, 2011, No. G043569 (Main Street Plaza v. Cartwright & Main, LLC)
Also known as
United States · · · 27-04-2011
Opinion
FYBEL, J.—
Introduction
Plaintiffs, owners of a retail center and food court, sought a judicial declaration that they had acquired a prescriptive easement for parking and access by their tenants’ customers, employees, suppliers, and other invitees, over an alleyway behind the owners’ property. The alleyway is located on *1047plaintiffs’ property and two adjoining properties. A railway easement ran along the same land as the alleyway; property taxes were assessed on the railway easement, and the holder of the railway easement paid those taxes.
Defendant owners of the two adjoining properties filed motions for summary judgment and summary adjudication. The trial court granted the motions and entered judgment, concluding that no prescriptive easement in favor of plaintiffs had arisen on defendants’ properties because plaintiffs did not pay property taxes on the separately assessed railway easement. Plaintiffs appeal.
We reverse the order granting summary adjudication and hold that because the railway easement was not coextensive in use with plaintiffs’ claimed prescriptive easement, payment of taxes by plaintiffs on the separately assessed railway easement was not an element of their claim for a prescriptive easement.
The trial court also granted the summary judgment motion filed by one of the adjoining property owners. Code of Civil Procedure section 437c, subdivision (g) requires that an order granting summary judgment (1) specify the reasons for the court’s determination and (2) refer to the evidence showing no triable issue of material fact exists. Neither the court’s minute order, nor the formal order prepared by the prevailing party, complies with these requirements. The two issues raised by the summary judgment motion were never addressed by the trial court at the hearing on the motion. The appellate record does not provide sufficient information to permit meaningful appellate review of these issues.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit