Civil Court of the City of New York August 31, 2011 (Smith v. Blavatnik)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-08-2011

OPINION OF THE COURT

Andrea Masley, J.

The trial began on August 2, 2011 and continued on August 3 and 4, 2011. Plaintiff Adrian Smith testified and called Wilfredo Balmaceda, defendant’s house manager, as a witness. Elizabeth Williams, executive assistant to Mrs. Blavatnik, testified for defendant.

This is an action for breach of contract in which Mr. Smith seeks damages in the amount of $5,000 for unpaid consulting fees.

It is undisputed that Mr. Smith assists clients who wish to hire domestic servants. It is also undisputed that from April 2006 to May 1, 2008, Mr. Smith ran a licensed employment agency to place domestic staff. (License, exhibit 18.) Mr. Smith credibly testified and reiterated throughout the trial that the work he did for Mr. Blavatnik was identical to the work he performed as a licensed employment agency. It is also undisputed that Mr. Smith is no longer licensed as required by General *426Business Law § 172. As an unlicensed employment agency, any agreement Mr. Smith may have had with Mr. Blavatnik is unenforceable. (CPLR 3015 [e].) Therefore, Mr. Smith lacks standing to bring this action and the action is dismissed with prejudice.

Even if Mr. Smith were licensed or a license was not required, he failed to establish that he had an agreement with Mr. Blavatnik or that Mr. Blavatnik breached such an agreement. Mr. Smith’s testimony that “it was a given” does not establish an agreement to be paid by Mr. Blavatnik.

The credible testimony and evidence established that after Mr. Smith “cold” called either Mrs. Blavatnik or Ms. Williams in February 2011, and offered his services; he was referred to Mr. Balmaceda. Mr. Smith and Mr. Balmaceda communicated by phone and email from February through April 2011. Mr. Smith referred a number of potential applicants to Mr. Balmaceda. While Mr. Balmaceda interviewed a few candidates, none were hired. Although he was unsuccessful in placing any applicants in the Blavatnik home, Mr.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.