Supreme Court of Minnesota December 28, 2011, No. A11-0450 (Roby v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-12-2011

OPINION

GILDEA, Chief Justice.

Appellant Gary Roby was convicted of aiding and abetting the crimes of first-degree premeditated murder, first-degree murder while committing aggravated robbery, and second-degree intentional murder for his role in the shooting death of Marlizza McIntyre. We affirmed Roby’s conviction on direct appeal. State v. Roby (Roby I), 463 N.W.2d 506 (Minn.1990). In this case, Roby appeals the denial of his third petition for postconviction relief. Because we conclude that the postconviction court properly denied Roby’s petition, we affirm.

The facts surrounding Marlizza McIntyre’s murder are set forth in detail in Roby I. Id. at 507-09. We limit our discussion of the facts to those directly relevant to this appeal. McIntyre was killed by one shot to the back of her head while she was being held down and robbed on May 22, 1989, in the kitchen of a Saint Paul apartment. Lillian Dunn-Simmons, Kenneth Fisher, L.Y., A.J., S.L., appellant Gary Roby, and two of appellant’s brothers were all in the apartment at the time of the murder.

Fisher testified that on the day of the murder, yelling and screaming from the kitchen of the apartment woke him. When he went to investigate the noise, he saw McIntyre being held face down on the floor. Dunn-Simmons and appellant’s brothers were holding McIntyre down while Roby straddled McIntyre’s back and removed some of her jewelry and at least $80 from her bra. Fisher testified that Roby pulled out a revolver, pulled back McIntyre’s hair, and shot her in the back of the head.

S.L. also testified that McIntyre was killed by a shot to the back of the head. But she said that Dunn-Simmons fired the fatal shot while an unknown black man held McIntyre down. The State, however, impeached S.L. with two prior statements in which she had indicated that the man holding McIntyre down was, or could have been, Roby.

L.Y.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.