Michigan Supreme Court April 25, 2011, 141122 (People of Michigan v. Naykima Tinee Hill)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-04-2011

Order Michigan Supreme Court

Lansing, Michigan

April 25, 2011 Robert P. Young, Jr.,

Chief Justice

141122 & (51) Michael F. Cavanagh

Marilyn Kelly

Stephen J. Markman

Diane M. Hathaway

PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF MICHIGAN, Mary Beth Kelly

Plaintiff-Appellant/ Brian K. Zahra,

Cross-Appellee, Justices

v SC: 141122

COA: 290031

Saginaw CC: 07-028869-FC

NAYKIMA TINEE HILL,

Defendant-Appellee/

Cross-Appellant.

_________________________________________/

On March 9, 2011, the Court heard oral argument on the application for leave to

appeal the May 11, 2010 judgment of the Court of Appeals and the application for leave

to appeal as cross-appellant. On order of the Court, the applications are again considered.

MCR 7.302(H)(1). In lieu of granting leave to appeal, we AFFIRM the judgment of the

Court of Appeals in part. Trooper Escott was not required to be qualified pursuant to

MRE 702 because he was not testifying as an expert witness. Rather, he simply testified

to the underlying facts and his personal observations concerning his use of a trained dog

in the course of a criminal investigation. He did not interpret or extrapolate from those

facts or personal observations.

We REVERSE the judgment of the Court of Appeals in part because the

admission of Jacqueline Sistrunk’s out-of-court statement that she saw defendant wearing

“a brown-hooded coat with fur around it,” was harmless error because it is clear beyond a

reasonable doubt that the jury verdict would have been the same absent this error. People

v Shepherd, 472 Mich 343, 348 (2005). The prosecutor presented eyewitness

identification testimony of the three victims who each independently identified defendant

as their assailant. Such identification testimony was clear and unambiguous, and

occurred after each victim had a full and sustained opportunity to observe defendant

during their 25 to 30 minute ordeal.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.